Unlockable: Apache Shirt
Finish the Hunting Missions.
Unlockable: Cavalry Sword
Beat Reed.
Unlockable: Dual Peacemakers
Beat Hoodoo Brown.
Unlockable: Silver Spurs
Finish all Pony Express Missions
Successfully complete story mode and all side missions (100%
completion) to unlock Reed's armored horse, Magruder's seven barrel
Nock gun, and the Cannon Nock gun.
(Although i reccomend being a man and having the whole fight)